Case Analysis
One Level Up The Fine List Getting Started SWOT Guidelines Outcomes Running The Game Thinking Strategically Performance Measure Peer Evaluation KSF Case Analysis



 

 

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. CASE PROFILE

A.Time Frame of the case

B.Industry (overview and brief history)

C.Company (overview, size of the company, and brief history)

D.Issues (identify the key strategic management issues in the case)

 

II. SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS

A.EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT

Globalization

(interdependence among industrialized countries, needs of developing countries, lower barriers for money, information, and technology flow)

Economic

(inflation, interest rates, GDP, trade and budget deficits, savings rates)

Technological

(products, processes, and materials)

 

Demographic

(population’s size, age structure, geographic distribution, ethnic mix, and distribution of income)

 

Sociocultural

(attitudes, culture)

Political/Legal/Regulatory

(anti-trust, taxation, regulation , labor laws)

 

 

 

B. INDUSTRY ANALYSIS

 

 

PORTER’S FORCES

Threat of New Entrants and Barriers to Entry (ADDRESS ALL)

(economies of scale, product differentiation, capital requirements, switching costs, access to distribution channels, cost disadvantages independent of scale, government policy, expected retaliation)

 

Intensity of Rivalry Among Competitors (ADDRESS ALL)

(size and strength of competitors, slow growth, high fixed or storage costs, low differentiation, capacity added in large increments, diverse competition, high stakes, high exit barriers)

Product Substitutes

(low switching costs, lower price/performance)

Suppliers

(concentrated, few substitutes, not important to suppliers, suppliers’ differentiated product or switching costs, possible forward integration)

Buyers

(concentrated, purchase much of your product, significant portion of their costs, they buy undifferentiated products, few switching costs, earn low profits), possible backward integration, unimportant in their quality)

 

STRATEGIC GROUPS (ADDRESS THIS PLEASE)

Who else is in their strategic group? Justify your response using the following dimensions:

 

Dimensions

(technological leadership, degree of product quality, pricing policies, distribution channels, customer service)

C. COMPETITIVE ENVIRONMENT ANALYSIS

(general statement regarding the competitive environment)

 

Competitors’ Strategies and Core Competencies

(customers, distribution, marketing, sales, advertising, financial- who are their competitors, and what are their core competencies)

 

Action/Response History

(What has happened in the industry/how has this particular firm responded)

D. ENVIRONMENTAL TRENDS

 

Industry Life Cycle

(Emerging, Growth, Shakeout, Maturity, Decline - Justify your response)

 

 

SUMMARY:

ATTRACTIVENESS OF EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT

(brief wrap-up of the key threats and opportunities in the external environment

Note: This is different from the SWOT analysis)

E. STRATEGIC ANALYSIS

1. KEY SUCCESS FACTORS

(important dimensions that define success in the industry

refer to handout)

 

2. STRATEGIES

Business Level

(Cost leadership, Focused Low-Cost, Differentiation, Focused Differentiation, Integrated Low Cost/Differentiation)

Competitive Strategy

(first mover, fast second, slow second, late mover , a.k.a. pioneers vs. followers)

Corporate Level (ALL THAT APPLY)

Stable Growth Strategy

Growth Strategy

Concentration Strategy

Market Development

Product Development

Horizontal Integration

Vertical Integration

Diversification

Concentric (related) diversification

Conglomerate (unrelated) diversification

Levels and types of Diversification

Source: Adapted from R. P. Rumelt, 1974, Strategy, Structure and Economic Performance (Boston: Harvard Business School).

 

Low levels of diversification

Single-business: Over 95% of revenues come from a single business.

Dominant-business: Between 70% and 95% of revenues come from a single business.

Moderate to high levels of diversification

Related-contrained: Less than 70% of revenues comes from the dominant business, and all

businesses share product, technological, and distribution linkages.

Mixed related and Less than 70% of revenues comes from the dominant business, and there

unrelated (related-linked): are only limited links between businesses.

Very high levels of diversification

Unrelated diversification: Less than 70% of revenues come from the dominant business, and there

are no common links between businesses.

 

Harvesting Strategies

Defensive Strategies

Turnaround

Divestment

Liquidation

Filing for Bankruptcy

Becoming a Captive

Combination Strategies

Simultaneous

Combination

 

 

Modes of Entry (DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL)

(exporting, licensing, strategic alliances, acquisitions, internal

venturing, joint venturing, establishment of new subsidiary)

(what & with whom?)

 

 

 

 

 

3. CORE COMPETENCIES

a. RESOURCES

TANGIBLE

Financial

(borrowing capacity, ability to generate internal funds)

Physical

(location and sophistication of a firm’s plant and equipment, access to raw materials)

Human

(training, experience, judgment, intelligence, insights, adaptability, commitment, loyalty of workers and managers)

Organizational

(planning, controlling, and coordinating systems)

INTANGIBLE

Technological

(patents, trade marks, copyrights, trade secrets)

Resources for Innovation

(technical employees, research facilities)

Reputation

(brand name, perception of product quality, durability, and reliability, supplier relationships, culture)

 

 

b. CAPABILITIES

VALUE CHAIN

Inbound Logistics

Operations

Outbound Logistics

Marketing and Sales

Service

Infrastructure and Governance

HR

Technology

Procurement

 

 

 

SUMMARY:

SUSTAINABLE COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE

(brief wrap-up of the key strengths and weaknesses in the firm’s internal environment

 

Note: This is different from the SWOT analysis)

F. PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL

FOR one (1) PROFITABILITY RATIO, one (1) LIQUIDITY RATIO, one (1) LEVERAGE RATIO, and one (1) ACTIVITY RATIO, PLEASE DISCUSS 1, 2, and 3:

 

 

1) Trend Analysis (Intra-Company comparison for at least three years)

 

2) Comparison to Industry Ratios (Inter-Company comparison for at least three years).

3) Discussion of WHAT is happening and WHY

 

NOTE : In this section, please identify the INDUSTRY used to calculate your ratios. Also, please include the NUMBERS for ALL RATIOS (Firm and Industry) and a DISCUSSION of one ratio per category (a total of four).

Profitability Ratios

Year Firm/Industry Year Firm/Industry Year Firm/Industry
Return on Total Assets

Return on Stockholders’ Equity (ROE)

Return on Investment (ROI)

Operating Profit Margin

Net Profit Margin

 

 

Liquidity Ratios

Year Firm/Industry Year Firm/Industry Year Firm/Industry
Current Ratio

Quick Ratio

Inventory to Net Working Capital

 

 

 

Leverage Ratios

Year Firm/Industry Year Firm/Industry Year Firm/Industry

Debt/Assets

Debt/Equity

Long-Term Debt/Equity

Times- Interest- Earned (TIE)

Fixed Charge Coverage

 

 

Activity Ratios

Year Firm/Industry Year Firm/Industry Year Firm/Industry

Inventory Turnover

Fixed Assets Turnover

Total Assets Turnover

Accounts Receivable Turnover

Average Collection Period

 

 

 

III. SWOT (refer to SWOT handout)

 

 

STRENGTHS OPPORTUNITIES
WEAKNESSES THREATS

 

 

 

 

IV. STRATEGY FORMULATION

(Given the information in your case analysis, what strategy would you recommend to this company i.e., Where are we now? Where do we want to go.)

V. STRATEGIC ALTERNATIVE IMPLEMENTATION

(How should your recommended strategy be implemented? i.e., How will we get there?)

VI. EPILOGUE

(Case UPDATE from the time that the case ended in the text)

 

 

 

 

PLEASE INCLUDE ONE (1) ORIGINAL TABLE/CHART/GRAPH/DECISION SUPPORT TOOL

This model should incorporate concepts from the text.

Please explain and discuss your model.

 

 

NOTE: NA’s are NOT an acceptable response. Please answer ALL sections and all sub-sections of the case analysis handout. Most, but not all of the requisite information is contained within the case write-up. However, you will need to use other sources to supplement the case as it is written in the text, i.e. the library, the Internet, and your mind.

 

NOTE: This is a general framework for most cases. See me if you

have any questions about your particular case.