KH 2360 Reflection Paper – Grading Rubric
Name:
___________________________________ Semester:
Spring 2010
Total _____/26=________
| Criteria | 0-1 points | 2 points | 3 points | 4 points | Weighted Total |
| Reflection Critical thinking and Creativity | Misunderstands key concepts. Significant errors in content, interpretation of the material. Reflection not relevant to material. | Understands key concepts but is unable to draw inferences. Information presented has some errors. | Understands key concepts and draws valid inferences. Articulately reflects ideas, opinion, and alternate approaches | Student understands the depth and breadth of the subject matter fully and all related concepts. Quality of work suggests personal reflection. Work is of exceptional quality | ____x 2.5
|
| Citations | Work appears to have been done quickly with little emphasis on quality. Appears to quote at times but provides no documentation | Uses minimal resources from course to complete the assignment. No integration of sources into reflection | Selects 1-2 references with limited integration of references into paper | Cites 3 or more appropriate sources to effectively integrate and assimilate material | ___x 2
|
| Structure of Paper | Chaotic, disorganized presentation of material. No support of predictions and inferences. | Associate, digressive, elliptical, or circular presentation of ideas. Little support of predictions and inferences. | Articulates ideas . Adequate support of predictions and inferences is provided. | Demonstrates growth and maturation of ideas. Reflections build on general knowledge-base and includes exceptional support of predictions and inferences. | ___x 1 |
| Grammar and Mechanics | Frequent use of poor grammar, sentence structure, and spelling | Uses correct grammar yet has some spelling and sentence structure errors. | Uses correct grammar. and spelling, yet has some sentence structure errors. | Writes eloquently free of all grammar, spelling and sentence structure. | ___ x 1 |